Skip to content
CCG Insights

Insight

  • Insight

Challenging Times for Challenger Banks

Challenging Times for Challenger Banks

Challenging Times for Challenger Banks

Consumers love digital banking, but what about digital banks?

There is pessimism in the digital banking community following the news about Finn, the digital brand launched by JPMorganChase about a year ago whose impending closure was announced last week.

The announcement prompted questions about who the users of such accounts are and why they failed to connect with Finn. It appears there is a lack of information about what exactly users are looking for (if anything) in digital-only banks, so the industry is in a testing phase, experimenting with a wide variety of approaches.

Some of the offerings, such as Finn, come from the bank side. Finn was built on top of JPMC’s existing platform, but launched in a market where the bank had no branch presence. With the right marketing, this could be a promising growth strategy, but it was not clear why a new brand with no brand equity was chosen. Perhaps the powers in the old bank were never on board with the new effort, so it was given only a year to find its market fit. As fintech players know, this is not nearly enough time.

HSBC also had a digital-only offering in the U.K. called Connected Money, which the bank recently announced it would close down. Connected Money offered more money management functionality than Finn, including linking multiple accounts, and HSBC said it would incorporate some of this functionality into its primary app. This learning makes HSBC’s digital bank adventure more of a success story than Chase’s.

Other deposit offerings come from the fintech side, such as the investment platforms such as Robinhood and Acorns, as well as SoFi and standalone digital banks such as Chime. Some of these offerings have achieved scale, while others struggle to amass users. These accounts are built on newer platforms and leverage existing digital customers. It is still expensive for truly digital companies to acquire customers, but their overhead is lower because they have no branches.

Yet more offerings are beginning to come from the technology side, from Uber’s still vague foray into financial services, Amazon’s secured credit card, T-Mobile’s account powered by BankMobile, and more. Uber announced yesterday it was staffing up in New York (where the fintech talent was said to outweigh San Francisco’s, per CNBC) to launch an unspecified suite of financial services products aimed at deepening engagement with its core platform of human and food delivery.

Amazon’s offering is noteworthy not because it is a deposit account, but because the company is generally seen as the greatest big tech threat to banking, and is well positioned to leverage a loyal customer base into further product use. But Amazon is not infallible itself — the company recently admitted defeat and shuttered its food delivery service, which could not gain traction against Uber and established services such as GrubHub. Just as well — a drone would make a mess of your pizza.)

Who is attracted to digital-only accounts? Are they millennials or Gen Z consumers who don’t care about the branch? Are they older customers using the services as secondary accounts for budgeting purposes? It’s not yet clear. Most surveys of bank use by demographic groupings don’t even include digital banks — they’re simply not yet a factor.

Finn was a curiosity even by this experimental era’s loose standards. Postmortems noted the service had few distinguishing features to add value above a traditional account. The only concession was a $100 signup bonus, which is common to many banks, digital or traditional, in this time of deposit-hunting. Finn stood in stark contrast to Wells Fargo’s Greenhouse, which, though also a brand from a megabank built on top of a legacy core, offers two separate accounts, one for bills and fixed costs, and the other for less predictable expenses and entertainment.

This two-account strategy may help Greenhouse avoid the role Chris Skinner of the Finanser blog describes for challenger bank accounts – an account that does not receive a direct deposit but is instead used for occasional expenses. He wrote, in 2018:

“Before you know it, the big banks will just see statements that say: Monzo (auto top-up) £200.00. You know that I am doing things on Monzo, but you have no idea what, why or where I’m doing it. In other words, the financial intermediary who never believed they would be disintermediated, has been disintermediated by a new intermediator. A data intermediary. The lifeblood of the bank’s future – customer data – has been stolen by a new middleman: the intelligent intermediator.”

Such estimates now appear too optimistic, or at least too soon. Digital banks will need to offer clearly superior services to the right market, and these are still early days. Who will find their niche in time?

The fear for banks was always that new digital brands are looking to steal the customer experience, but there is also traction on the backend, among the tangle of pipes and wires and APIs that power accounts. Perhaps the real threat to banks is coming from behind.

https://twitter.com/leimer/status/1138456290362109952?s=20
 
—-
Subscribe to CCG Insights.

You Might Like These, Too

The Apple Card Is Changing How Users View Payments

The Apple Card Is Changing How Users View Payments

Collaboration Accelerators

Collaboration Accelerators

Why Google Plans to Offer Checking Accounts

Why Google Plans to Offer Checking Accounts

SMEs Show Interest in Embedded Finance

SMEs Show Interest in Embedded Finance

Leaders in Bank Consulting

About CCG Catalyst
Latest Insights
CCG

PHOENIX • NEW YORK • LONDON • SINGAPORE

Phone: +1-480-744-2240  • Contact Us

© 2023 CCG CATALYST CONSULTING. Privacy Policy & Terms of Service.
Request a Call Back
Linkedin Twitter
Subscribe
to our Insights
Subscribe
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
Cookie SettingsAccept All
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT
BANK
FINTECH
FUSION
  • About
  • Services
  • Insights
  • Fintech
  • Research
  • Team
  • Contact
  • Press
  • Careers
  • Events
  • RFI / RFP
  • Terms
  • Privacy
Linkedin Twitter Search
Subscribe for Insights

CCG INSIGHTS FOR BANKS, FINTECHS, AND CREDIT UNIONS

The Fed, Real-Time Payments, Alexa and Apple P2P, Part of Payment Revolution
  • Weekly digest of what's new
  • New research snapshots
  • Exclusive access to banking and fintech research
  • Industry news
  • Invitations to webinars and webcasts